The London Court of Appeal has ruled that Apple must pay $502 million in damages to the U.S.-based company Optis Cellular Technology LLC. The decision marks a new chapter in the long-running patent dispute between Apple and Optis over 4G technology.
The dispute began in 2019 when Texas-based Optis sued Apple in London, alleging that the iPhone and iPad used its essential 4G technology patents without proper licensing. Optis claims these patents are critical to technological standards and is seeking compensation for their use.
Last year, the High Court of London ordered Apple to pay $56.43 million (plus interest), covering past and future sales for a specific period. However, Optis found the amount too low and appealed the decision, leading to new hearings in February and March of this year.
Ultimately, the Court of Appeal ruled in a partially redacted decision that Apple must pay $502 million for a global patent license covering the period from 2013 to 2027. This amount does not include interest.
An Apple spokesperson expressed dissatisfaction with the ruling and announced plans to appeal:
"Optis produces no products and exists solely to acquire patents and sue companies. We will continue to defend against such unfair payment demands," Apple said in a statement.
An Optis representative welcomed the decision, stating that it “corrected a flawed earlier ruling and represents an important step toward recognizing the true value of our patents in Apple devices.” They added that the company is committed to receiving fair compensation for its patents, which enable high-speed connectivity in millions of devices worldwide.
This ruling is the latest development in the years-long legal battle between Apple and Optis over FRAND principles—Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory terms for licensing standard-essential patents.
